ArenaNet talk:Guild Wars 2 suggestions/Professions

A new profession : Witch. Witches would have the trademark pointy hat, long (generally dark) robes, and vaguely long nose. Witches would have access to one-time-only skills like res signets, which automatically recharge after having gained Morale. Examples : The ability to transform another character into a relatively harmless animal, like a frog, which would replace all their skills with skills relating to the animal the Witch turned them into. Also, a Witch would be able to zoom around on a broom, and be able to change his (which would be a Wizard) or her (a Witch) appearance easily.
 * A Necromancer on a broom? i c wut u did thar

No proffesion
I'm slightly disscusted at the fact that a suggestion is deleted (Unless its pretty much a copy of a former more descriptive one). idk why this was deleted any reason? Or was it the mods didn't like it and didn't want ANet staff reading it? Please tell me, i want to know? if it was due to format could you have commented and then i could have improved it. Thanks --Lt Death 20:28, 24 September 2008 (UTC)
 * Anyone know the answer? I was serious with that suggestion, and i know many in game that will back me up. -Lt Death 18:56, 20 October 2008 (UTC)
 * I suppose i answered my own quest |I found the answer here Although i beleive my page had much mor detail explaining the pro's and cons. So was it deleted due to being in the wrong place? I don't want to make a mistake similar again. Thanks -Lt Death 16:45, 21 October 2008 (UTC)

My Rant,
watched trough the half of these suggestions. only a few of them are well-thought. Said "epic fail" at fiery slingshots. I would like to see the author experiment with it to be punched in the face with the ammo from the fiery slingshot (which burns the weapon literally). Also biomancer is lulzepicfail because every life-related profession is well-designed. The monk with healing, ranger in symbiosis of nature, necromancer reaping from death. Also there are three or more bare-handed profession ideas. I'm pretty sure that the quality of these suggestion pages (Reason gaps, poor wording, repeated suggestions, lack of considering the GW world) is what driving arenanet staff members from the suggestion pages. So this page is basically a load of shit designed to increase the gap between the playerbase and the developers.

Solution A: Many players would be pleased if this whole suggestion subset was removed (in a reasonable amount if time to let authors save their ideas on their userspace/computers), because it has little if no effect on GW2, and defiles the spirit of Guild wars.

Solution B: Restriction to keep the spirit of Guild wars.

Borotvaltgandalf 20:35, 2 December 2008 (UTC)


 * A general issue with these pages, check the parent page of this page for details. But it's true this page is especially bad, since I'm not generally maintaining it.


 * For now, you are welcome to put delete tags on pages you think need to go. If no one else cares about them, which will often be the case, they'll be deleted in three days. Backsword 20:45, 2 December 2008 (UTC)

/ Phantom /

Phantom: basically a Human that has been touched and Corrupted by the Mists

Attributes: -flail mastery : How to attack with a Flail -Mist Power:Powerful Hexes associated with the Afterworld -Suffering arts: Skills that give the ability for you to actually "banish" people the way Shrio Tagachi does, skills that can scramble an opponent's skills, and more -rimary Profession: Repentism: for every point spent on this,ennemies atack 5% slower

how do you make a suggestion for this. Cause i would like to make suggestion of a grappler and or brawler.

Imbalanced
People, shut up with the "might not work becaus it could be imbalanced". It's pointless to say like that, becaus every single class, player-made or dev-made, can come imbalanced. --88.112.91.132 12:48, 8 April 2009 (UTC)