Category talk:Unreplicable unique items

From Guild Wars Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search

Should this category include non-max greens, many of which are only technically "unreplicable" because they have non-max mods? I personally do not think they count, as unreplicable otherwise means that an item has mods which could not normally coexist on that item (such as two inscriptions, or a focus mod on a staff...). I'll wait a bit before doing it, in case there is some reason that they should be included, but as it is, the category is inconsistent (by only containing some non-max greens and not others) and/or incomplete. Ailina 22:45, 25 March 2010 (UTC)

Just because it would be undesirable isn't a reason for exclusion. But then again, someone who wanted to be really prepared for PvP wouldn't get them for that reason, as they might for the others. Manifold User Manifold Jupiter.jpg 23:16, 25 March 2010 (UTC)
I think they should stay. They're green items that can't be replicated. Correspondingly, the ones that are missing should be added. -- FreedomBoundUser Freedom Bound Sig.png 23:52, 25 March 2010 (UTC)
I think they should be removed if they can be replicated from monster drops, particularly if all it takes is a couple mods and an inscription. Who cares if you can't craft a weaker version; that's silly. --76.22.247.48 02:02, 30 December 2010 (UTC)
Actually, I just noticed something. We already have a Category:Low requirement unique items. That's where those items belong. They shouldn't also be a part of this category. They are essentially different than the "true" unreplicable weapons. As Freedom said, the low-req weapons CAN be replicated using monster drops and non-maxed mods. They don't belong in this category at all, especially since they already have their own category. Unless there is stong (and reasoned) dissent, I'll remove the low-req unique items from this list tomorrow. Ailina 04:35, 8 January 2011 (UTC)