Feedback talk:User/Unstable/Dishonorable

Your premises have numerous errors in them. While I agree completely that the dishonor system sucks, it doesn't for the reasons you suggest. For example, you do not get dishonor for reporting someone else. You only get dishonor if nobody else reports them (the "1/3" of your team number is hogwash, despite its presence on this wiki).

What you may have seen is:

You report someone. You call that person out. That person reports YOU. Nobody else reports that person.

In this situation, you CAN get dishonor. But, in my experience, only if the same set of circumstances (ALL of them) were present in a previous battle within the previous hour.

My preferred fix would be to give leavers several hours of dishonor automatically and irrevokably.

Leeches who leech two matches in succession (with only dishonor in-between) would likewise get hours of dishonor.

Dishonor should stack for days or weeks, not hours. If you can't manage to look at your screen for the five minutes it takes to get into a match, you deserve dishonor.

NOTE: These suggestions would also make it much harder to bot. Daddicus 01:34, 27 October 2011 (UTC)