Guild Wars Wiki:Arbitration committee/2007-12-16-User:Erasculio

This page was created due to this request for arbitration by User:74.62.153.41.

Issue at hand

Erasculio stands accused of trolling.

Decision about accepting the case for arbitration

The case for or against acceptance is on the discussion page, and open for input.

• Decline - Erasculio and Armond had a small personal feud going on, but other users intervened before it got out of hand and both stopped. No need for arbcom. --Xeeron 15:22, 19 December 2007 (UTC)
• Decline - As Xeeron and Rezyk have pointed out, this request for arbitration seems premature, since the incident in question was fairly isolated and short lived. Even if it had been more severe, there are other options that need to be attempted before bringing a case to the ArbComm, such as contacting the users in question directly, and requesting attention and and assistance from the the rest of the community at GWW:RFC or GWW:NOTICE. --Dirigible 00:25, 20 December 2007 (UTC)
• Decline - I don't feel as strongly as my two colleagues about the decline vote. I think that Erasculio and Armond allowed their arguments to become disruptive to the wiki at large. While I agree that the arbitration request is premature I hope that both users in question will reflect on why someone thought arbitration was necessary. LordBiro 21:01, 21 December 2007 (UTC)