User talk:St Lucretia/Skills/Warrior/Shielded Defence
From Guild Wars Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
This skill, by far, overpowers probably every other protection spell. 68 Damage reduction for a 3 sec recharge skill!? Think about it with Mo/W: 25 damage reduction is a lot. Titani 
Ertan {{Snappy the Turtle}} 19:53, 17 August 2009 (UTC)
- When i looked at 1 adrenaline and 1 second recharge.... WTF?! It would be overpowered, even as an elite! - J.P.
Talk 21:28, 17 August 2009 (UTC)
- Reduced damage reduction at both ends and increased recharge to 3. I wanted this to be a good spammable tanking skill or a quick self-prot spell for warriors, getting that balance right is tricky. Suggestions?
St Lucretia 21:51, 17 August 2009 (UTC)
- I like this skill. If you use it well, then it's great. If you use it badly, then it gets wasted on a staff hit. Should go back to previous reduction now that it's 3
, otherwise it's not too useful against crazy high damage ele spells. P.S. Don't try to say this would be too good for monks. Much worse than Armor of Sanctity. -~=Sparky 
(talk) 08:39, 19 August 2009 (UTC)
- Dude, you just gave every warrior out there an enormous shield and damage reduction. It is wwayy overpowered. This much damage reduction shouldn't exist unless it is very long recharging. Titani
Ertan {{Snappy the Turtle}} 08:47, 19 August 2009 (UTC)
- Even if this IS used well, it isn't that extreme. If you're in the front-lines you're no way guaranteed to reduce that big hit instead of a tiny staff. St Lucretia 08:52, 19 August 2009 (UTC)
- Exactly. Look at Reversal of Fortune, Life Sheath, Reversal of Damage, Xinrae's Weapon, and Protective Spirit. Obviously it already does exist in a very not long recharging way, with much better effects (not to mention using them on allies). -~=Sparky (talk) 09:15, 19 August 2009 (UTC)
- Exactly. Look at Reversal of Fortune, Life Sheath, Reversal of Damage, Xinrae's Weapon, and Protective Spirit. Obviously it already does exist in a very not long recharging way, with much better effects (not to mention using them on allies). -~=Sparky
- Even if this IS used well, it isn't that extreme. If you're in the front-lines you're no way guaranteed to reduce that big hit instead of a tiny staff.
- Dude, you just gave every warrior out there an enormous shield and damage reduction. It is wwayy overpowered. This much damage reduction shouldn't exist unless it is very long recharging. Titani
- I like this skill. If you use it well, then it's great. If you use it badly, then it gets wasted on a staff hit. Should go back to previous reduction now that it's 3
- Reduced damage reduction at both ends and increased recharge to 3. I wanted this to be a good spammable tanking skill or a quick self-prot spell for warriors, getting that balance right is tricky. Suggestions?
