I have played many MMORPGs and offline RPGs over the years,
including Eye of the Beholder, Fallout, Baldur's Gate & Neverwinter Nights, Ultima Online, EverQuest and even World of Warcraft.
Current GW satisfaction: I am again playing GW. It still has something, despite all the many issues.
I hope GW2 does not continue the downtrend of grind based title hunting and stuff like that.
GW works only without grind, as a grinder it is subpar to fully fleshed out MMOs.
Want to see my Chars?
Check Guild Wars Characters - a GW char database.
Feel free to add your chars, too! The page is run by Pakuna Bob, and has 27521 registered users with 95906 chars (13th Oct 2010) so far.
I enjoyed the War in Kryta immensely, and while I am still 3 titles shy of "GWAMM" I made 50/50 and Champion of the Gods on 2010/10/13!
Now I just hope there will be a digital CE of Guild Wars 2. Not that I would not like a box, but I don't want to wait for the mailman on launch day.